Skip to main menu Skip to main content Skip to footer
Pay Bill Online
Shop Readers & Accessories
Order Vitamins
Order Contacts


VisionFirst Eye Care

Located in front of Regal Theatre and Meijer, the VisionFirst New Albany office is easy to spot! If you live in Southern Indiana, we invite you to come check us out for all your vision care needs. Our manager, Jackie Pineo, has a lot of experience working in the vision world and does an exceptional job running the New Albany office. We promise you won’t find better eye care anywhere else in New Albany! 

Insurance, Frames, and Lenses

We have a large selection of over 1,000 frames to choose from and our experienced staff is there to help you select the perfect frames to LOOK your best. We accept most insurance plans, including VSP, Davis, EyeMed, and Unicare. Check out our comprehensive list of accepted plans.

Plus we now carry the Essilor family brand lenses including Transitions, Crizal, Varilux and Xperio.

Experienced Doctors

Doctors Carol Hickey, Jennifer Reynolds, and Rebekah Todd provide comprehensive vision care at our New Albany office. That includes prescribing glasses and contact lenses, diagnosing and treating ocular diseases and providing pre and post-operative care for cataract and laser vision correction surgery. They each fit all the major brands of contact lenses, including lenses for astigmatism and multifocal correction, as well as specialty contact lenses.

All of our doctors are members of the American Optometric Association, and doctors Hickey and Reynolds are members of the Indiana Optometric Association.


Every doctor has a special interest or area with additional expertise. Dr. Carol Hickey, for example, served four years as an optometrist in the U.S. Navy and loves working with our servicemen and women to this day. She also enjoys giving pediatric eye exams and has a lot of experience working with children.

Dr. Rebekah Todd is an expert at pediatric eye exams as well. She is a participating provider for InfantSEE®, a free eye assessment program for infants ages 6-12 months. Your children will feel especially comfortable with these two, we can assure you of that!

Dr.Todd specializes in amblyopia (lazy eye), binocular vision, and learning-related vision problems. Together, Dr. Hickey, Dr. Todd, and Dr. Reynolds make a great team for bringing you vision care you can trust!

Office Hours:

Monday – Friday: 9:00am – 6:00pmSaturday: 8:00am – 2:00pm


4326 Charlestown RoadNew Albany, IN 47150Phone: (812) 945-0023

VisionFirst would love to be your resource for eye exams, eye care, and eyeglasses in Southern Indiana. We want to help you SEE Your Best, LOOK Your Best and FEEL Your Best!

If you live in New Albany, schedule an appointment today with one of our trusted doctors, or stop by and let one of our opticians help you find that perfect frame!